hmm well...
maybe you dont need a religion itself...like me...ofc i joined the buddhist side but i am not following their "rules". its more like my own views and beliefs did match nicely with it but in the end i follow my own beliefs. like i practise buddhism but the same time i do believe in some sort of magic like the pagan one.
mix the things you feel right and take a look if there is some belief where it comes close. sure there is still no need to join any religion...i could have refrained from joining them but i felt its ok with me. its kind of nice to have people around you who at least share similar beliefs and views of the world, even if they surely wouldnt agree with me on other aspects of my own world views.
like you can be a good christian even if you dont go to church each sunday...but ofc other christians might not feel this way. each one has to decide what is right or wrong and not let other decide what to do.
but sure this would raise a point...are you a worse christian if you dont attend the church each week? are you bad if you dont pray each day? would god love you less and think badly of you?
and thats where i think if it makes you feel good and if you dont feel guilty (not cause others tell you so) all should be fine. whether its islam, christianity, buddhism, pagan aso.
i shape the world around me how i see fit and as long as i have a clear conscience its fine with me.
a long time i was a logic thinking person and more science based with no belief at all. the day a friend introduced me to them (god bless his soul cause he died this month) i found myself feeling at home....so many things were matching with my own views but still i could keep my other views about magic, gods, science and anything else without anyone telling me "you are wrong!".
no one put pressure on me and even if i stay away a long time...they welcome you back with open arms anytime, not blaming you for staying away...rather being glad you once joined their ranks.
thats what made me feel welcome, without any worries i felt at home and at peace.
trust me...i was surprised myself that i found belief in me...even if i still have this doubts from thinking logically. but hey...even a priest sometimes thinks god has forsaken him and has doubts. so all is fine ;)
or at last...you just need time and fate, coincidence or whatever will let you find what you are looking for somewhere in the future.
P.S.: i am sick of digging snow...my back hurts